|
By
Ron Todt of the Associated Press
Cambridge University professor Simon Baron-Cohen
thinks he knows why autism strikes four times
as many boys as girls, but his theory of general
differences between male and female brains has
generated quite a bit of debate.
Baron-Cohen theorizes that the female brain is
predominantly hard-wired for empathy, and that
the male brain is predominantly hard-wired for
understanding and building systems - although
he is quick to note that
the rule doesn't always hold true.
According to his "empathizing-systemizing"
theory, autism - a neurological disorder that
affects social interaction and communication -
and the possibly related Asperger syndrome are
extreme male versions of the brain.
"What seems to be core (to autism) is an
empathy problem alongside a
very strong drive to systemize," he told
an audience of about 150 people
Wednesday at an autism conference by the Bancroft
Neuroscience Institute.
Baron-Cohen cites evidence from questionnaires,
psychological tests and observations of very young
children showing early sex differences. Even
day-old baby boys, for example, are more likely
to look longer at a mechanical mobile, while girls
look longer at a person's face.
Autistic-type disorders, he said, appear to be
an extreme version of the male brain. What causes
such a shift is unclear, he said, but possible
candidates include genetic differences and prenatal
testosterone. High levels of fetal testosterone
mean less eye contact on the part of infants,
and Canadian researchers have found that such
levels mean better scores on systemizing tests,
he said.
Baron-Cohen said his ideas and his new book "The
Essential Difference:
The Truth About the Male and Female Brain,"
had been greeted with interest
rather than the hostility he feared after "decades
of political correctness"
in which the idea of any biological sex differences
was anathema.
"Some individuals have contacted me to say
that this kind of work is
politically dangerous, so that reaction is still
there," he said.
"Typically the individuals who are worried
by this approach haven't actually looked at the
details of the science."
He emphasized that the male and female brains
exist only on average.
"It would be a great shame if people took
home the idea that all males
think one way and all females think the other
way," he said. Instead,
educators should assess each individual child
to see if, for example, they
are good at math but may have trouble on the playground,
he said.
Researchers have come up with educational software
to try to help raise the emotional abilities of
autistic children, and a study of the approach
should be finished in the next few months, he
said.
Martha R. Herbert, an assistant professor in neurology
at Harvard Medical School, said Baron-Cohen's
observations were interesting, but still had not
identified a biological process responsible for
autism.
"As to whether there's some core thing about
male or femaleness that's
related to autism, I doubt it," she said.
"I think that it just distracts attention
from getting at some of the more core issues of
how the disorder works both psychologically and
biologically."
A British researcher, for example, has found that
the sex ratio was equal in autistic blind children,
and that there is a different sex ratio in high
IQ versus low IQ people with autism. "So
it's not just a male thing; there's something
else going on," she said.
Work focusing on high levels of testosterone may
be more revealing, but is still not the end of
the story, Herbert said.
"The testosterone may be facilitating something
rather than causing it," she said.
|