3rd ed, by Christopher
Gillberg and Mary Coleman, 330 pp, $95, ISBN
1-898683-22-0, London, England, MacKeith Press,
2000.
Reviewed by Andrew W. Zimmerman, MD
[This thanks to Lee Irwin's autism newsletter.
Subscribe to his
publication by sending e-mail to leeirwin@crosslink.net
with the message"subscribe autism-advisor"
http://archneur.ama-assn.org/issues/v59n3/ffull/nbk0302-3.html
This updated classic provides clear direction
through the uncharted
waters of the emerging field of autism. The title
defines the heterogeneity of autism and the text
follows a logical course, with chapters on the
clinical diagnosis of different subtypes, associated
disease entities, current science, epilepsy, and
the neurology of autism.
The areas of neuropsychology, genetics, and biochemistry
are especially well covered and the references
are exhaustive. In addition to updating new findings
in imaging, neuropathology, and neurochemistry,
this edition carefully delineates clinical subtypes
of
autism and the association of autism with known
genetic and medical disorders ("double-syndromes").
The authors show, in each of the 19 concise and
well-written chapters, the shortcomings of current
knowledge, and lay out strong guidelines for further
research. Although at times "Eurocentric"
in their viewpoint, the authors even-handedly
cover the entire scope of literature on the subject.Their
willingness to clearly discuss popular therapies
(such as secretinand applied behavioral analysis)
make this text useful for practitioners not familiar
with the field as well as for knowledgeable parents.
One shortcoming is a lack of useful figures and
illustrations, such as imaging studies and neuropathologic
and electroencephalographic findings. While the
chapter on genetics nicely outlines findings for
each chromosome from both chromosomal and molecular
studies, it could have been enhanced by figures
or tables. The discussion of placebo effects,
lack of randomization, small sample sizes, and
definition of subtypes in autism drug studies
are concepts just now beginning to be appreciated.
In the final chapter on neurology, a "classical"
approach to localization leads to a provocative
discussion of
the possible origins and timings of lesions in
utero that lead to
maturational defects in autism.
Few authors have so ably covered the entire field
of autism, with openness to new ideas, emphasis
on the importance of evidence-based treatments,
and sensitivity to the rights and needs of persons
with autism.
http://www.feat.org
|