|
In
the current edition. Not available online.
Armed with a new study, some parents say vaccines
trigger autism. But is skipping shots the answer?
Mike and Lynne Koufakis say their son Jake came
into the world a healthy, happy child. Babbling
and smiling as a newborn .he seemed to be developing
normally. But at 18 months, not long after he
received his routine childhood vaccinations, he
started to change.
"He began slowing down," says Lynne.
45, a stay-at-home mom in Manhasset. N.Y. 'He
lost eye contact and began withdrawing. He was
a space cadet, out of it."
Now 8, Jake Koufakis bus been diagnosed with autism
-- the second
child in his family to have the disorder-and Mike
and Lynne Koufakis
believe the vaccinations are partly to blame.
Their youngest, Jenna, 5, shows no signs of autism,
but her frightened parents have stopped vaccinating
her
altogether. The Koufakises have joined a growing
number of parents who
suspect Thimerosal -- a mercury-based preservative
once commonly used in
childhood vaccines -- may be a factor in an apparent
explosion in autism
cases in recent years. Experts have long said
there is no scientific data
to support such fears, but a study published in
June by Columbia University
has re-ignited the debate.
The report -- presented to a congressional sub
committee Sept. 8-shows Thimerosal triggered autism-like
symptoms in a strain of mice genetically susceptible
to autoimmune disorders (as are many autistic
children). While far from conclusive, activists
say the study offers some evidence that outside
factors like high mercury levels, not genetics
alone may play a part in the rising autism diagnoses.
"Parents I know believe there is a connection
between vaccines and autism," says Lee Grossman,
chairman of the Autism Society of America. "It's
shocking to find a lifelong disability at such
high levels. If it were cancer, people would be
all over that."
Commonly used for more than 70 years, Thimerosal
has been phased out
of all childhood vaccines since 1999; now it is
present only in tiny
amounts in some inoculations. The ingredient remains
in most flu shots, which the Centers for Disease
Control and Prevention now recommends for children
between 6 and 23 months (see box). That fact has
fueled reluctance to
immunize children-to the frustration of doctors.
Vaccines prevent potentially devastating illness:
says Dr. Gary Freed, professor of pediatrics at
the University of Michigan Medical School who
cared for a child who died of complications from
measles because he hadn't been immunized. "His
parents will never forgive themselves-their child
died of a disease that could have bacon prevented."
As for the Columbia research, Dr. Alfred Bert
who participated in a lengthily Institute of Medicine
study that rejected any connection between vaccines
and autism, says. 'It's a leap to translate what
happened to the mice into the autistic behavior
of children."
That doesn't matter to parents like Lyn and Tommy
Redwood of Tyrone.
Ga. Lyn, 47, a nurse, and Tommy, 46, an ER doctor,
were alarmed when their
son Will stopped talking in his second year. After
he was diagnosed with
autism Redwood began doing Internet research and
had Will's hair samples
tested for mercury. It contained near-toxic amounts
of the substance --
nearly five times EPA-sanctioned levies The Redwoods
believe Will absorbed
mercury via childhood vaccinations, injections
Lyn took while she was
pregnant. And pollution) "I don't know who
is responsible." says Lyn, who
launched SafeMinds, a group that promotes the
idea that mercury in
vaccines is dangerous. All I know is I have a
child who isn't able to isn't able to live up
to his potential The devastation felt by families
like the Redwoods is perhaps the only thing all
parties in the autism debate agree on. The National
Institutes of Health says diagnosis have risen
front roughly one in 2,500 births in the 1960s
to one out of 500 today. Experts cite different
causes for the jump, among them a broadened definition
of the disease.
"A lot of things that weren't considered
autism in the past are now lumped
under that term." says Dr. Thomas Saari,
spokesman for the American
Academy of Pediatrics. In Sweden, where Thimerosal
was eliminated in 1993 the number of cases continued
to rise. "People are desperate for an explanation.
They want to understand what happened to their
child," says Melinda Wharton, acting deputy
director of the National Immunization Program
at the CDC. But we have to go with science-not
what people feel."
|